Tuesday 9 April 2019

LA FORZA DEL DESTINO, Royal Opera House, 2 April 2019



Giuseppe Verdi LA FORZA DEL DESTINO,
 Royal Opera House, 2 April 2019 (Cinema Relay)


CAST

Marchese di Calatrava..........................................ROBERT LLOYD

Leonora di Vargas................................................ANNA NETREBKO

Curra, a maid.......................................................ROBERTA ALEXANDER

Don Alvaro..........................................................JONAS KAUFMANN

Don Carlo di Vargas............................................LUDOVIC TEZIER

Alcalde................................................................MICHAEL MOFIDIAN

Maestro Trabucco...............................................CARLO BOSI

Preziosilla............................................................VERONICA SIMEONI

Padre Guardiano................................................FERRUCCIO FURLANETTO

Fra Melitone......................................................ALESSANDRO CORBELLI

Surgeon...............................................................JONATHAN FISHER


Chorus and Orchestra of the Royal Opera House
Conductor.......................................................   ANTONIO PAPPANO

Producer............................................................CHRISTOF LOY



A great triumph for the Royal Opera House in every respect. This opera has not in the past been one of my favourites, although I have always loved the music. This production, however,  managed to turn this rather daft Victorian melodrama into a thing of beauty. I wonder if there will ever again be such a fortunate conjunction of cast, conductor  (Antonio Pappano) and orchestra?  I will never forget this as long as I live.

It may be the best performance that Anna Netrebko has given.




It can't be an easy role to play.....poor Leonora never has one moment of happiness....well, perhaps a fleeting few seconds before their flight is thwarted by her father and the inevitable tragedy ensues. I loved the soaring high notes in 'Pace, pace, mio Dio' and the passion and commitment  she brought to this tragic character. Whatever she tries to do, however sincerely penitent she is, she can't find peace, so tormented by the memories the death of her father and the loss of Alvaro.

However, this wasn't  a case of the the star soprano dominating the scene, the connections between the characters were truly reciprocal.....the relationship between Carlo and Alvaro has a lot of sub-text, I think, depicted with great intensity by Jonas Kaufmann and .Ludovic Tezier.





The performance of 'Solenne in quest'ora' broke my heart........almost a thwarted bromance!!  There is no better pairing than Kaufmann and Tezier, and in this performance they took the scene to heights of sublimity.



And their later confrontation is even more intense and tragic because of what came before.......Alvaro's fate is tied up with the whole Calatrava family, not just Leonora...it's almost as if Alvaro is thinking.....I have to kill you, but that's not really what I want to do.....
..


In this production, the crowd scenes scene with Preziosilla seemed a bit extraneous.....very well performed, but something of an irrelevance.....I assume that was Christof Loy's point. Veronica Simeoni was a very attractive and smooth-voiced Preziosilla. In the crowd/circus scene, I especially liked the Street Vendor, who reminded me of Cut-My-Own-Throat Dibbler, a character created by Terry Pratchett.

It was certainly cast from strength..... I was particularly happy to see beloved veteran Robert Lloyd as the Marchese di Calatrava, and Feruccio Furlanetto as Padre Guardiano. 

I liked the staging, although it has attracted some unfavourable comments. It is one set, based on a room in the mansion of the Calatrava family, which accommodates all the other scenes as well. I thought this was quite effective, especially in the final scene....I realise they are supposed to be in the monastery where Leonora has taken refuge, but the fact that it resembles the claustrophobic home in which Leonora was trapped at the beginning means that the wheel has come full circle..Alvaro and Leonora are re-united when it is too late.


.....During the overture, there was a staging of a 'back story', the childhood of Leonora and Carlo.....with another brother, who dies. It shows that Leonora never really had a chance.....claustrophobic childhood to doomed adulthood.
(In the play on which LA FORZA DEL DESTINO is based.....LA FUERZA DEL SINO.....there are in fact two brothers. Alvaro kills Carlo in their duel, then the other brother....Don Alfonso...tracks him down and forces him to fight a duel.....Alvaro kills Alfonso too).

This was one of the best performances of anything I have ever seen at the Royal Opera House. 

1 comment: